City & Sports

Editor’s Note: That soccer game didn’t go well

City & State plays hard against Mamdani’s City Hall.

Journalists from many competing outlets united to play the beautiful game.

Journalists from many competing outlets united to play the beautiful game. Ethan Stark-Miller

The soccer game ended about as badly as you could possibly imagine.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and his communications team handily defeated the City Hall press corps, 8-5 on Nov. 19 (though the exact score is an all-too-typical matter of dispute between the reporters and the press office). One of those goals was scored by the mayor himself, on a shot that went through my own legs as I tried to defend him. The mayor then proceeded to do “finger guns” in the face of this humbled defender. “Was that Heard Around Town?” Mamdani later asked, a biting reference to City & State’s insider newsletter.

But pride goeth before a fall.

With just five minutes left in the match, Mamdani dropped to the turf, untouched, and grabbed his leg. It was a torn Achilles tendon. And this little soccer game, which was meant to be a quiet way to strengthen professional relationships between journalists and the city’s press officers, soon became international news.

City & State’s Sahalie Donaldson was a standout star of the journalists’ team, and our Annie McDonough and Shenal Tissera contributed too, while I really should have stuck to the sidelines. (To be fair, Annie had little time to practice, after working sources all week to connect the web of insiders and allies around House Speaker-designate Hakeem Jeffries, for next week’s cover story.)

While Mamdani became the story, it was the dozen-or-so staffers who carried his team – the city employees who are on the other end of our calls, texts and emails. We’ll maintain a healthy, adversarial stance toward the Mamdani administration in our stories, just as we did on the field. Good competition makes everyone play their best.