Winners & Losers

This week’s biggest Winners & Losers

Who’s up and who’s down this week?

This week's biggest Winners & Losers.

This week's biggest Winners & Losers. City & State

 It’s always election season in New York. We’re not even through the 2021 elections and yet the 2022 cycle is already barreling towards us. It’s far too soon to predict winners and losers in next year’s contests, but state Sen. Brian Kavanagh got some bad news this week as socialist Alana Sivin declared her intention to primary the Democratic senator. Kavanagh won’t be the only incumbent facing a progressive challenger in 2022 – or probably in any future cycle. But before we get ahead of ourselves musing about winners and losers of the future, let’s take a moment to appreciate all the wins and losses of the past week. 


Mary Bassett -

There is just something about the former New York City health commissioner that left-leaning legislators and medical professionals can’t help but love. Progressive cred and progressive bonafides are the source of much praise for her nomination as state health commissioner. She also has an established track record of handling disease outbreaks without withholding nursing home data from elected officials and the general public. That was just too darn hard for her scandal-plagued predecessor despite all his fancy degrees,

Cordell Cleare & Yudelka Tapia -

Anyone will tell you – sometimes the voting public get it wrong. So even though Cordell Cleare got 4th place in her third unsuccessful run for New York City Council and Yudelka Tapia got 2nd place in her second unsuccessful run for office, the pair will almost certainly be heading to Albany in January anyway. Cleare as the county committee’s choice to replace former state Sen. Brian Benjamin in Harlem, and Tapia as the insiders’ pick to fill retired Assembly Member Victor Pichardo’s seat in the west Bronx.

Meisha Ross Porter -

Few would disagree that Meisha Ross Porter took on a difficult job when she became New York City Schools Chancellor earlier this year. But between the rise of the delta variant and the task of implementing a controversial COVID-19 vaccine mandate, Porter has had a particularly bumpy road to travel in starting her first new school year. That’s why the official go ahead from a federal appeals panel to enforce the vaccine mandate this week is a win for Porter. Sure, she’ll still be the one to catch flak from disgruntled staff, but at least vaccinations are rising.


Eric Goldstein -

Would you eat a chicken nugget with metal in it for $67,000? Yeah, probably. Would you serve the nuggets to kids for that price? Absolutely not. And that’s where New York City Department of Education executive Eric Goldstein went wrong, according to federal prosecutors who say he pocketed the bribe to get the tainted nugs back on the menu. That crossed a line, even in this city of street meat, dollar slices and dirty water dogs. 

Kevin Henderson -

If you’re in law enforcement and lose the support of your union, you know you’re toast. Ontario County Sheriff Kevin Henderson resigned over allegations he made sexual, homophobic and racist remarks. It comes after weeks of controversy following the announcement of an investigation into the allegations, as well as his inaction to address such remarks made by others. Then came a vote of no confidence from the union repping sheriff’s department staff. With subpoenas issued, Henderson must have seen the writing on the wall and stepped down.

Ray Sanchez -

One of the city’s largest homeless shelter operators got the boot this week from the Department of Homeless Services. City Limits first reported that Aguila Inc., which has a history of financial mismanagement and hazardous conditions, will no longer run the men’s shelter inside the Park View Hotel. The decision was reached as the city does an audit of its shelter system to eliminate bad agencies. Aguila CEO Ray Sanchez failed to reform the notoriously problematic but politically connected nonprofit.