Opinion

Editor’s note: Zohran’s Mamdoppelgänger

Being confused for the mayor can happen when you play him on stage.

Jeff Coltin and Zohran Mamdani at the Inner Circle Show.

Jeff Coltin and Zohran Mamdani at the Inner Circle Show. Katie Honan

The first time I remember being mistaken for Zohran Mamdani was at the National Action Network Convention last year.

I was reporting on his interview with the Rev. Al Sharpton from the front of the hotel ballroom. And minutes after the surging mayoral candidate stepped off the stage, a couple of older ladies – I can’t speak for their eyesight – clasped my hand and told me I did a great job up there.

I don’t look that much like Mamdani. But when you’re working in New York politics as a 30-something light-skinned man with a brown beard who often wears a suit and tie, you kind of invite the comparison.

This can feel … uncomfortable at times. My job is to look at the mayor not look like the mayor. But it did get me a big role in the Inner Circle Show, where my fellow journalists and I had fun critically spoofing City Hall on stage. And it was there that Mamdani, of Indian, Muslim descent joked that I, of white, Jewish descent, “look like a version of me that could have actually won the Upper East Side.”

And the vague resemblance has kicked off some great conversations, like when I grabbed a cab in White Plains last week. “Are you Mamdani’s brother?” the driver said. “Love that guy.” A Haitian immigrant, he said he stayed up all night watching the news when Mamdani won. “Get outta here Cuomo!”

To mark the mayor’s first 100 days, City & State focused not on his (dashing good) looks, but on how he’s been handling the job. He was careful with his words in a sit-down interview with City Hall reporters Sahalie Donaldson and Annie McDonough. But we dug through it all: the good, the bad and the ugly.