Opinion

Editor’s note: Celebrating press freedom at the LCA Show

We should err on the side of press access, even if it makes for some bad videos.

The cast of the LCA Show

The cast of the LCA Show Darren McGee/Office of Gov. Kathy Hochul

I took the train to Albany last week, not to see the budget get passed (we were still waiting on that one) but to see the LCA Show – the 124-year-old comedic revue performed by the capitol reporters of the Legislative Correspondents’ Association.

City & State’s Kate Lisa sang in character as Gov. Kathy Hochul, the “accidental leader” running through running mates – “hope third time’s the charm!” – while Hochul and her partners in government sat laughing (and cringing) in the front row. Then – just like in the Inner Circle Show (the city version I’m proud to be a part of) – Hochul takes the stage and dishes it right back, skewering journalists in a stand-up routine.

It’s hilarious, but it’s also a proud demonstration of the freedom of the press and the independence of the LCA.

But the show went on amid a debate over access to press passes in New York City. It feels wrong that social media influencers would be covering the Luigi Mangione trial while publicly defending the defendant. But I don’t think that city government should do anything about that.

I’ll gloss over the intricacies and nuances of the press pass system and declare simply that I don’t want the government determining who is and isn’t a journalist based on their politics or point of view. I’d prefer we err on the side of press access – even if that means that some press pass holders will reflect poorly upon the professional work done by City & State journalists and our colleagues.