Opinion

Opinion: Let the experts decide on federal school vouchers

Trump’s so-called “freedom scholarships” are a Faustian bargain, and whether New York participates in the program should be up to the Board of Regents.

State Sen. John Liu has introduced a bill to let the NYS Board of Regents decide whether to opt in to Trump’s “freedom scholarships” program.

State Sen. John Liu has introduced a bill to let the NYS Board of Regents decide whether to opt in to Trump’s “freedom scholarships” program. NYS Senate Media Services

President Trump may call them “freedom scholarships,” but no matter how he tries to spin it, the federal school voucher program his administration stuffed into last year’s so-called Big, Beautiful Bill is a Faustian bargain designed to divert resources away from public schools.

Whether or not New York participates in such a consequential program should ultimately be the decision of the Board of Regents, a deliberative body free from the prevailing politics of the day. They are the education experts whose primary responsibility is statewide education policy and who are best positioned to weigh the pros and cons of entering into a voucher program and ensure accountability in education funding.

School vouchers have long been debated and routinely rejected in New York because they run the real risk of taking funding away from public schools. Only recently has New York finally fulfilled our constitutional obligation to provide every student with a sound basic education by fully funding Foundation Aid. This was achieved with great fanfare thanks to the efforts of Gov. Kathy Hochul and the state Legislature, and it is why we simply can’t afford to risk jeopardizing the firm footing we’ve established for our public schools on this slippery slope.

Supporters of Trump’s vouchers say if we don’t opt in and let individuals claim up to $1,700 in federal tax credits, we’re leaving money on the table, but this is misleading. First, it’s important to remember the Trump administration is cutting education funding with one hand while offering to subsidize these vouchers with the other. So while opting in may not have a short-term effect on the state budget, make no mistake that the long-term fallout could be disastrous.

Meanwhile, advocates want to use the vouchers to pay for essential education services like after-school programs, tutoring, and special education. But should our public school families be forced to seek private scholarships to receive the services public schools are legally mandated to provide? That is outrageous. Public schools, which serve the vast majority of New York’s children, should never be sliced and diced in service to Trump’s vouchers. 

The Scholarship Granting Organizations through which these vouchers must be administered also raise serious questions, as they operate with little to no direction from state authority. There’s no doubt that the subsidy will only grow in the future, leading to even more education tax dollars being redirected to a voucher program capable of funding private schools that operate under different accountability standards than public schools.

For this reason, I’ve introduced legislation to give the New York State Board of Regents the sole authority to decide whether New York should participate in this federal voucher program. For well over 200 years, the regents have been decision makers for education policy in New York. As an independent entity, free from political influence, the regents are uniquely positioned to weigh the pros and cons of federal school vouchers and even administer them should they deem them worthy.

Importantly, this legislation does not forbid New York from participating in the voucher program. Federal law gives states the choice to opt in. The bill simply gives the authority to make that decision to the experts in New York state education: the Board of Regents.

It is telling that the vast majority of states that have already opted in are controlled by Republicans. Our neighbors like Connecticut and New Jersey, and other Democratic-run states like California, Massachusetts and Michigan, have asked for further clarification on the rules promulgated this fall, taking the necessary time to evaluate such a consequential decision, New York should, too – and the Board of Regents has the expertise to do that evaluation. 

Now that voters across the country, including here in New York, have so overwhelmingly rejected the Trump agenda in the midterms, it makes even less sense for New York to enter into this Faustian bargain. We must recognize it for what it is – a deal with the devil that betrays our values and shortchanges public education. 

Let’s not forget Trump is the same president who takes outsized pride in framing the indefensible as greatness, describing the Jan. 6 insurrection as a “day of love” conducted by “patriots.” Likewise, his so-called “freedom scholarships” in his equally Orwellian “Big, Beautiful Bill,” is akin to tax credit candy – it looks delicious and may even taste good at first, but it’s a bitter pill to swallow down the road nationally and especially in New York state.

The Trump administration may think dressing up school vouchers with double talk will make it more appealing, but New York has long held to the principle that public tax dollars should fund public institutions that serve a public good, and every student is entitled to a sound, basic education. Public schools must educate all children, regardless of ability or background and without discrimination. 

With so much at stake, let’s let the experts decide, not any one government or administration.

John Liu is a state senator representing the 16th Senate District in Queens and the chair of the Senate’s New York City Education Committee.

NEXT STORY: Editor’s note: 333 pages down, in ‘Power Broker’ marathon reading