Labor

Amazon, National Urban League threaten to sue city if Delivery Protection Act passes

The Mamdani-backed bill to end third party contracting has drawn the ire of business groups.

New York City Council Member Tiffany Cabán’s bill is backed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani – but it has its critics, too.

New York City Council Member Tiffany Cabán’s bill is backed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani – but it has its critics, too. Alex Krales/NYC Council Media Unit

Civil rights group the National Urban League and a coalition of business organizations spearheaded by Amazon are threatening to sue if the New York City Council passes controversial legislation that would require big delivery companies to directly hire delivery workers.

In a letter sent Monday to City Council Speaker Julie Menin and other members of the legislative body, attorney Derek Sells urged them not to vote for the Delivery Protection Act in its current form, citing several concerns – such as the bill’s potential to wipe out dozens of the independent businesses contracted by online delivery retailers like Amazon, thus eliminating thousands of jobs. 

“Given the severity of these impacts, particularly to business owners and workers of color, my

firm has been retained to evaluate the legality of the legislation,” reads the letter, which was shared in advance exclusively with City & State. “My conclusion is that Intro 518 directly conflicts with existing federal and state law and raises serious legal questions about the city’s authority to enact it.” 

First introduced by Council Member Tiffany Cabán in February, the legislation has ignited increasingly heated debate since Mayor Zohran Mamdani came out in its favor this summer. 

Supporters like the mayor, Teamsters Local 804 and the New York City Central Labor Council tout it as an important worker justice measure – one that would force Amazon and other big delivery companies to take full responsibility for the “last mile” delivery and warehouse workers they currently employ through third-party contractors. They argue that the subcontracting system is rife with exploitation, allowing Amazon to dictate hiring standards, delivery routes and productivity quotes while denying that delivery workers are employees. 

The bill’s opponents claim that the measure would drive up delivery costs, slow the arrival of packages – and, in the case of the National Urban League, which began campaigning against the measure last month – potentially force small delivery businesses to close without compensation, many of which are Black-owned. Amazon meanwhile has threatened to close warehouses and move thousands of workers out of the city if the legislation passes. Amazon has also funded a multi-million dollar ad campaign and lobbying effort, under the banner of the Five Borough Jobs Campaign. 

Sells, National Urban League President Marc Morial and the New York Delivers Coalition are slated to hold a press conference in Harlem Monday morning to discuss the potential legal challenge.  

“The city should not be putting itself in a position of passing something only to see it challenged,” Morial told City & State. “There are constitutional flaws in this legislation.”

The National Urban League’s website cites Amazon as one of its “diamond partners,” meaning the civil rights organization has received more than $1 million in donations from it. A spokesperson for the National Urban League did not immediately say how much Amazon has donated to the organization in total.

There’s been no movement on the legislation within the council since April, when the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection held a hearing for it. Menin told reporters last month that, despite the mayor’s public advocacy for the bill, lawyers for the Mamdani administration have expressed concerns about its legality. According to The New York Times, Menin is open to the possibility of amending the legislation, including potentially scrapping the proposed ban on hiring through third-party delivery companies. This is something the letter urges the City Council to do. Other less controversial pieces of the legislation include requiring operators of last-mile warehouses and storage facilities to obtain licenses from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.

Menin has previously defended the bill, despite the big money being spent against it. 

“It’s time for Amazon to adhere to a licensing framework that ensures fair pay, strong worker protections, and more responsible delivery practices that don’t leave vehicles idling on our streets for hours,” Menin said in a statement. “I am determined to pass a bill that both protects these workers and keeps these jobs in our city. We can and must do both.”