New York City

Mamdani seeks Rikers closure by 2032

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is releasing a long-awaited plan to close Rikers Island. The new closure deadline still needs the City Council’s approval.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani wants to close Rikers Island by 2032.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani wants to close Rikers Island by 2032. Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a detailed blueprint for how his administration will at long last shutter the troubled jails complex at Rikers Island, setting the stage for a new wave of negotiations with the City Council over when the transition to four smaller borough-based jails must be completed. 

The mayor’s highly anticipated plan, which was released Friday morning, laid out a framework to close Rikers Island by the end of 2032 – 13 years after the City Council, under former Mayor Bill de Blasio’s administration, initially set the legally mandated closure deadline for August 2027. Mamdani alone doesn’t have the authority to set a new date. Like his predecessor, he’ll need the City Council to pass legislation to do so. 

Council Member Selvena Brooks-Powers, chair of the Committee on Criminal Justice, stopped short of confirming that the legislative body will move the deadline to the end of 2032, but expressed optimism that everyone appears to be moving in the same direction. The City Council’s current plan is to convene members of the Mamdani administration and criminal justice advocates in December for an oversight hearing to consider legislation to move the date. The main bill, which has yet to be introduced, will be sponsored by City Council Member Sandy Nurse. 

“I’m thankful that the mayor is taking seriously the need to extend the deadline, recognizing that 2027 is not feasible,” Brooks-Powers told City & State. “In our hearing and future discussions, we will be able to determine what that true date is, but I think we are moving right now in a good way towards a common goal.”

The legislation will include some type of incremental benchmark dates to hold the Mamdani administration accountable, according to Brooks-Powers.

“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said in a statement. “We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers. Working alongside the City Council, courts and nonprofit partners, we will meet it – for the people in our custody, the staff who serve them, victims of crime, and every New Yorker.”

The 2032 deadline would fit with the anticipated timeline for constructing the new jails – something that can’t be said for the existing 2027 deadline. Brooklyn’s facility is the first of the borough-based jails slated for completion, opening in 2029. It’s scheduled to be followed by the Bronx and Queens facilities in 2031 with the final jail, in Manhattan, expected in 2032, according to City Hall. But construction is just one piece of the puzzle. 

It was obvious long before Mamdani took office that the city would need to set a new deadline to close Rikers Island. Former Mayor Eric Adams repeatedly questioned the plan throughout his tenure, citing the ballooning population incarcerated in city jails. Today, the number of people behind bars still remains the biggest obstacle. As of June 1, the incarcerated population stood around 6,700 – down from 7,000 during the prior administration, but still well above the roughly 4,500 people the new borough-based jails are being built to hold. 

Bringing down the population is a big piece of the Mamdani administration’s plan, which sets a goal to reduce the number to no more than 4,100 people, including no more than 220 women by the end of 2032. (The current incarcerated population is overwhelmingly male.) The plan also allocates $30 million in fiscal year 2027 and another $260 million through fiscal year 2030 towards various initiatives to help facilitate the population decrease, like piloting new pretrial alternative to detention programs, expanding pretrial advocacy teams to challenge unaffordable bail, working with the state Office of Mental Health to expand access to psychiatric beds and increasing services for those leaving city jails. 

The administration also touted efforts it has made to move people in Department of Corrections custody into alternative locations – such as a 104-bed housing unit for people with acute medical needs at Bellevue Hospital Center – and the resumed work on a supportive housing project in the Bronx that would provide 58 studio apartments to previously incarcerated people. But the population still has a long way to drop.  

The plan’s release comes mere days after Elizabeth Glazer, the former head of de Blasio’s Office of Criminal Justice and one of the leading organizers of the original plan to close Rikers Island, wrote an opinion piece in The New York Times arguing that Mamdani can and should focus on rebuilding or renovating jails on Rikers Island into “safe, humane facilities” while continuing to build the neighborhood-based jails.

Still, this moment is the product of months of building momentum. With new leadership at the helm of city jails – including Department of Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards and remediation manager Nicholas Deml – advocates have increasingly begun to hope that the long-standing cycle of violence and dysfunction plaguing Rikers Island might soon come to an end.

Zachary Katznelson, executive director of the Independent Rikers Commission, described the plan as “a real commitment” from the Mamdani administration – that alone, he said, is a major change from the prior administration. He also lauded the mayor for taking so many recommendations from the detailed blueprint the commission released last year on how the city can close Rikers Island. 

“Closing Rikers really is essential towards moving to a safer and better New York,” Katznelson said. “Moving to something far better really is critical for our city.”

Correction: This story has been updated to clarify that Glazer argued in The New York Times that the Mamdani administration should focus on rebuilding and renovating the jails at Rikers Island into safer facilities while building the new jails.

NEXT STORY: Hochul admin generating support for nuclear power