2026 Midterms

Constantino won – but he’s still fighting his defamation suit

Lawyers for state Conservative Party Chair Gerry Kassar said the representative-elect dragged his feet on setting a deposition hearing, but there are signs of a breakthrough.

Rep.-elect Anthony Constantino will succeed outgoing Rep. Elise Stefanik in the North Country.

Rep.-elect Anthony Constantino will succeed outgoing Rep. Elise Stefanik in the North Country. Jim Franco/Albany Times Union via Getty Images

The attorney representing state Conservative Party Chair Gerry Kassar in an ongoing defamation lawsuit against Rep.-elect Anthony Constantino claims the Sticker Mule CEO is refusing to sit for a deposition to delay the case. Constantino, however, says he’s “looking forward” to it.

Kassar’s attorneys filed a letter this week asking Judge Desmond Green, who’s overseeing the defamation case in state Supreme Court in Brooklyn, to intervene and set a date for Constantino to appear for a deposition and hold an immediate conference in court. 

The letter was first reported by RawStory. Since the letter was filed and City & State began reporting this story, attorneys for both parties have been in communication about scheduling.

In July 2025, Kassar filed a defamation lawsuit alleging Constantino made public statements falsely accusing him of threatening to kill the sticker magnate, and accusing Kassar of falsely ordering the murder of Constantino’s spokesperson Paul Antonelli. The spokesperson is still alive.

Constantino filed a motion to dismiss the suit, but this past January, the judge denied it. In February, Kassar's attorneys sought to question Constantino under oath.

Kassar and Constantino’s ongoing legal battle is just one key example of the incoming Republican member of Congress’ fights with the state’s political establishment – many of whom see him as brash and unprofessional. 

It was a point of contention for the party for months – ahead of a tense intraparty battle for new leadership – and caused his narrow victory that should have been a landslide. Constantino, who is on track to defeat Democrat Blake Gendebien by just over a percentage point in a district that Donald Trump won by 20 points in 2024. Constantino was the only New York Republican to win a House race this year without also running on the Conservative Party line – a fact he has been bragging about in social media posts. 

Meanwhile, Kassar admitted he was rooting against Constantino, in a Facebook comment Friday. “I did not want an embarrassment to win,” he said, “which is why I took the recommendation of the local leaders to leave the line blank.”

Earlier this year, the court temporarily delayed all proceedings in Kassar’s suit until after the election – and both parties agreed that Constantino would quickly provide dates to schedule his deposition as soon as the election was over. But now, weeks after Constantino narrowly won the race to succeed outgoing Rep. Elise Stefanik in the North Country congressional seat. Kassar’s attorneys said in their letter that they contacted Constantino’s counsel to schedule the deposition several times, but to no avail. 

Constantino’s attorneys again refused to offer possible dates at a meeting between the opposing counsel on Friday, and claimed that Constantino wouldn’t voluntarily sit for a deposition in the foreseeable future, according to the letter.

“Mr. Constantino’s attorneys once again indicated that no matter how many times we propose new dates, Mr. Constantino will not voluntarily produce himself at any time in the foreseeable future, despite having no legal basis for such a refusal,” the letter reads. 

Constantino’s attorneys told City & State they hope the judge will answer the request by the end of the week. 

In a statement to City & State, Constantino said he’s “looking forward” to any future depositions and getting to the bottom of the case.

“While Chairman Kassar was busy suing me for telling the truth and trying to prevent my election, I was busy becoming the only congressman-elect to win without his Conservative Party line,” Constantino said. “I look forward to depositions and to a future for the New York State Conservative Party without its corrupt, gluttonous chairman who threatened me after I put up the Vote for Trump sign. Alternatively, if Chairman Kassar remains, I am also open to a future without a New York State Conservative Party, as it's clearly a big scam as long as that corrupt loser is in charge.”

Christian Browne, one of Kassar’s attorneys, said in response to the statement, “And we are looking forward to deposing Mr. Constantino. Since he’s eager to give sworn testimony, we look forward to his confirming his appearance so that he can answer questions regarding this matter under oath and discharge his basic duty to comply with the orders of the court.”

Constantino has embraced, and received mixed feedback, for using crass language on the campaign trail and since his victory. He has repeatedly called members of the media “evil,” and particularly called this City & State reporter “a fucking asshole” during his election night speech.