Opinion

Opinion: The case for closing Rikers remains strong

Opponents of closing Rikers haven’t changed their tune much since 2016.

An aerial view of the Rikers Island jails complex on Jan. 17, 2024.

An aerial view of the Rikers Island jails complex on Jan. 17, 2024. Andrew Lichtenstein/Corbis via Getty Images

Over a decade ago, a massive coalition of New Yorkers – individuals and families scarred by Rikers Island – came together to call for its closure.

The goal of the Close Rikers/Build Communities campaign was to shutter the entire jail complex, responsibly shrink the size of New York City’s pretrial population and invest in the types of programs that keep people from winding up in jail in the first place. 

Despite being initially laughed off by Mayor Bill de Blasio and others as a quixotic dream, the campaign steadily built community awareness about the horrors of Rikers, amassed political support for closure and passed city and state legislation to improve New York’s pretrial system. This was a historic, successful movement made possible by both advocates outside of government and allies inside of government who believed that a different criminal justice system was possible, one more in line with New York City’s values. 

Yet, nine years after the de Blasio administration vowed to close Rikers, and seven years after the City Council passed a resolution codifying the decision, we’re still reading in The New York Times that closing Rikers was merely a “slogan”, and that we should instead engage in “practical” solutions like building a new jail with state-of-the-art air conditioning on the island. 

It’s notable that opponents of closing Rikers haven’t changed their tune much since 2016, even in the face of significant progress both locally and nationally on how to reform the criminal justice system. In her op-ed, Elizabeth Glazer curiously focuses on the endemic culture of violence at Rikers, which has not abated under Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration, and argues that reforming jails on the island are the cure to this violence. 

The Close Rikers campaign has always argued that the jail complex’s century-long history of violence is driven in part by its location – out of sight, out of mind and inaccessible to the steady presence of nonprofits, defense lawyers and family visitors who could shed light on what is happening there. One of our refrains, backed by decades of history and failed commissions, is that “Rikers is beyond reform.” When jails are smaller, next to the courthouse (and defendants’ lawyers) in downtown areas that are accessible to families, these conditions can be mitigated, alongside a desperately needed culture charge at the Department of Corrections. 

Glazer also says New York City’s incarcerated population is too large to close Rikers. Even now, dealing with the aftermath of the Adams administration, the jail population sits at 7,000 – far less than the 11,000 people the jail held when the Close Rikers campaign started. Notably, that figure reached as low as 4,000 during the COVID-19 pandemic, proving that achieving the targeted numbers is attainable. 

If most of Glazer’s arguments are tired retreads of the ones she made while serving in the de Blasio administration, her new one is that the costs of closing Rikers have gone up, and the whole project has just become too complicated. As advocates, we never asked for the de Blasio administration to build four new borough-based jails. In fact, we were concerned that this would significantly extend the closure timeline. Our main slogan from the first rally after de Blasio unveiled a closure plan he knew he would not be in office to complete was “Ten Years Sucks.” 

The de Blasio administration dithered for much of its second term on the closure process, which increased construction costs, but the real problem was the Adams administration. Corrupt and inept from start to finish on a number of issues, including closing Rikers, the Adams administration didn’t even bother to comply with statutory mandates to transfer land from Corrections to the Department of Citywide Administrative Services, which was necessary to keep the closure process moving along.

That doesn’t mean closing Rikers is or was bad policy; it means that the previous administration couldn’t govern. That learned helplessness, so common to Democrats of the last generation, is at the crux of Glazer’s argument. Transforming the criminal justice system is too hard, so let’s just build a new jail on Rikers and cross our fingers. Fortunately, there is a new generation of Democratic leaders who emphasize deliverism and mobilize government to get things done. Mamdani is leading this charge.

Building a smaller, fairer and safer criminal justice system isn’t just an advocacy slogan. It’s a comprehensive set of policies to align New York’s jail and legal systems with its progressive values. To give up on that idea is to condemn another generation of predominantly low-income New Yorkers of color to a cesspool of corruption and violence. 

We can do better. We can keep investing in the types of community programs that reduce violence and keep people out of jail. We can bring the new borough-based jails online with new correctional standards and only hire correction officers with strong track records to work in them, which will lead to safer jails for both the people incarcerated there and the people who work there. We can keep reforming our court system so cases are actually resolved – something that would be made easier, not harder, by closing Rikers. 

There’s no reason a city as well-resourced as New York City, with its socialist mayor and ascendent local culture, should be home to the most notorious jail in America. Instead of listening to people who spent their careers running a broken system, let’s move forward and build a criminal justice system we can believe in.

Janos Marton is the CEO of Dream.Org. From 2016 to 2018, he managed the campaign to Close Rikers, and from 2024 to 2025, he sat on the city’s Rikers Island Advisory Committee.