Interviews & Profiles

‘A long way to go’: Tiffany Cabán on the new plan to close Rikers

The New York City Council member, whose district includes Rikers Island, talked about the new plan, growing momentum on the Delivery Protection Act, and the DeMarco-Liberty split.

New York City Council Member Tiffany Cabán at a stated meeting on Nov. 19, 2026.

New York City Council Member Tiffany Cabán at a stated meeting on Nov. 19, 2026. John McCarten/NYC Council Media Unit

Dozens of elected officials and advocates gathered in the City Hall Rotunda Friday to celebrate a new plan from New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration to close the troubled jails complex on Rikers Island by 2032.

For Council Member Tiffany Cabán, whose district houses Rikers Island, that date can’t come soon enough. City & State caught up with Cabán on Thursday about the plan and the work that still remains, growing momentum on her legislation to regulate Amazon’s delivery operation, priorities for the council’s Progressive Caucus, and – of course – where the New York Liberty go next. 

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

What do you think of Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s new plan to close the Rikers Island jails complex by 2032?

I think it’s important to note that Rikers is in my district. Part of the reason why I’m here in this body is because I came to politics through my work as a public defender. Unfortunately, we were set back a ton by the last administration, who really had no interest in actually investing in decarceration. It was like everything’s a nail, and we’ve got a hammer. I have appreciated the attention that the new administration has taken toward having a real concrete plan to close Rikers and to do it sooner rather than later.

I also understand that at this point, the current legally mandated timeline is a problem because the census on Rikers is higher than it was pre-pandemic. They’ve made some good hires – some folks that just are really smart folks, who are deeply aligned and understand that we are not going to incarcerate our way out of the city’s mental health crisis, the housing crisis, the overdose and substance use crisis. Investments are also being made toward programming for folks who are incarcerated. I would always like to see much more added in terms of preventative support – the things that are going to keep people out of jails to begin with.

The fact of the matter is, there is tension between those priorities and this administration’s policing priorities. We can’t have a police commissioner that says we are going to triple down on broken windows policing and think that you’re going to be able to get that jail population census down. I think we have a long, long way to go, and I certainly am committed, along with my colleagues, to work with the administration to make sure that this plan comes to fruition.

The biggest obstacle is bringing down New York City’s jails’ population. The mayor’s plan includes a good chunk of funding to do so, but there’s obviously other stakeholders like the district attorneys that have a role to play. 

Yes, and they’re elected independently. While there are so many people that are part of the incarceration machine that serve at the pleasure of the mayor, the DA’s are outside of that. And so it’s going to take some work to make sure that they get on board. That’s absolutely necessary.

What are you anticipating negotiations to look like between the City Council and the Mamdani administration? There’s going to be an oversight hearing in December. And I understand that whatever the City Council ultimately proposes as far as legislation goes will include benchmarks.

Yeah, and that’s similar to the original Renewable Rikers Act, right? There were benchmarks that absolutely were not met in terms of being able to transfer land from the Department of Correction to the Department of Citywide Administrative Services. (Council Member) Sandy Nurse has a new bill that will extend the timeline. It’s going to lay out benchmarks and needed conditions and investment, and it’s just going to be a continued process between the administration and the council.

The Delivery Protection Act is picking up a lot of steam. Are you in agreement with the speaker about amending the bill? 

There is a ton of alignment on the bill. We’re really excited about it. We have a veto-proof majority, we have the speaker’s support. We’re working on the final language of the bill that makes sure that what we are doing is addressing the safety crisis that we want to address. 

We are looking at an industry that has ballooned – a billion packages this year alone – and we’ve seen a race to the bottom with safety. 

We saw Amazon just cut a contract without notice last week – 200 workers out of a job. And the Delivery Protection Act, it addresses those things too. It addresses a corporation like Amazon’s ability to flout labor laws, which they’re doing each and every day. And there’s deep alignment with the speaker.

Will the City Council’s Progressive Caucus – which you co-chair – be going all-in pushing Council Member Chi Ossé’s CURB Act legislation that would limit the NYPD’s policing of protests?

Yes, it’s one of our priorities for a very good reason. We have seen a number of people who have been harmed simply for exercising their First Amendment rights. The thing I think back on is some of the 2020 protests. You had people protesting police violence only to be met with more police violence, and it cost the city just millions and millions of dollars in lawsuits. 

We need to codify this so that it’s something that lives longer and also holds the mayor accountable to his end of the deal. He can make a plan and implement it, but ultimately, it’s up to us to make sure that we’re doing the oversight and codifying this so that it’s not a similar unit just under a different name.

Is it the CURB Act or nothing? Or might we see a different version of the bill sponsored by a different member?

This is not about who the sponsor is. It’s about what the bill does. The CURB Act was written with people who have survived police violence, who have been part of these different protest movements on behalf of people, civil and human rights. This is a much needed public safety bill, and we’re going to keep pushing it.

Would you support a challenger to Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz? 

Listen, I – it’s been clear. I’ve recently helped lead a letter to the DA about the handling of cases, especially people who are being shot in the midst of being in a mental health crisis. We’ve seen that the conviction integrity unit, there’s not really much coming out of there. It’s a lot more status quo.

I want to see a DA, no matter who’s there, say that we’re not going to criminalize poverty, mental health and substance use disorders. That we are going to hold big corporate bad actors accountable. That we are going to engage in a robust conviction integrity practice, and all of these different things. Are we seeing that right now? No. And so whatever it takes to see that is something I would support. 

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is weighing a run for president or U.S. Senate, and you live in her district. Are you interested in running for Congress?

I’ve been asked this a lot, and I’m gonna be honest with people. If my amazing Congress member decided to run for higher office, I absolutely would consider running for the seat. 

My parents, before they ended up in the Woodside houses, were South Bronx kids. They grew up in the Millbrook houses, and I think about what the opportunities are, especially now with our federal government and the rise of fascism and Trump 2.0, and also the entrance of a lot of really exciting new leaders into Congress, the fights that could be waged and should be waged. 

Not to mention the fact that we are at a critical moment in Puerto Rico. I am a Puerto Rican with family still on the island, and it’s devastating there. And a big place of power to fight for Puerto Rican (sovereignty) and for the Puerto Rican people is in Congress. We’re losing “La Luchadora,” Nydia Velázquez. If (Rep.) Alex (Ocasio-Cortez) moves up, there’s going to be a void, and I want to continue to find ways to fight for my people and my community. And I think that’d be a pretty good place to do it.

The New York City Housing Authority is currently working with private sector developers to take down and rebuild buildings in the Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea housing developments. Some residents are staying in protest, hoping to fight it out, and others are relocating. The Save Chelsea Public Housing Coalition is demanding that they pay for the upgrades to the building instead of just demolishing. [NYCHA says] they don’t have the money for that. I was curious where you stand on the project.

That’s a community that is not my community, and so where I can talk about this is from the general housing lens. My parents on both sides of my family grew up in public housing. 

I remember so many different details about my grandmother’s apartment and, quite frankly, the shitty condition it was in. We hear it from constituents in my district all the time, and this is a problem that goes beyond just the city and the state. It’s the federal level too. We need an infusion of money to go into NYCHA to get repairs that are needed, so that people are living in dignified spaces. That is the true social housing, and we have to preserve it.

This is a crisis on different ends, and I think tenants and the people living in public housing have to be at the forefront of making decisions around what happens to the campuses that they live on.

Lastly, a non-politics question that I’m sure you feel very passionate about: How do you feel about the Liberty parting ways with Head Coach Chris DeMarco? 

THANK GOD! First of all, thank you for the question. I really appreciate it. I’m excited to see who ends up being brought in. 

From the jump, myself and so many others were like, there are so many talented women who should be taking on this role. It’s clear that DeMarco wasn’t a good fit in New York, and it was clear from the start that they really didn’t have his back.

We're a championship caliber team. We deserve a championship caliber coach that’s ready to be in the city and the culture of New York women’s basketball. They better get it right this time.