New York State
Hochul open to reforming Scaffold Law
Even after a fatal building collapse, the governor didn’t rule out tackling the prickly labor issue expected to dominate next session.

Gov. Kathy Hochul is considering taking on Scaffold Law reform next session, she said Tuesday. Rebecca C. Lewis / City & State New York
Amid calls for increased worker and construction site safety provisions in the wake of last week’s fatal building collapse in Brooklyn, Gov. Kathy Hochul said Tuesday she’s still exploring the prospect of reforming a long-standing safety law often blamed for high construction costs and hindering the building of more housing.
Speaking to reporters at an unrelated event in Queens, Hochul didn’t definitively say she would include Scaffold Law reform in her agenda next year. But she made it clear that the building collapse wouldn’t stop her from exploring ways to increase the production of housing when asked directly about the 140-year-old law around gravity-related work injuries.
“I went to the site on Sunday morning. To see the scale of that horrible tragedy is very eye opening,” Hochul said. “But I also want to make sure that this one incident doesn’t divert us from also looking at all the reasons why … we do not have building in the state, why we don’t have more housing available so people don’t have to live in such crowded conditions as they did in the next door building where there was such loss of life.”
The Scaffold Law is unique to New York and a frequent topic of debate – but the statute’s contentious nature has prevented significant reform from taking place. Proponents of the law – including politically influential construction trades – say it provides a crucial extra layer of protection and recourse for workers. Opponents argue the absolute liability it imposes in instances of injuries due to faulty safety equipment significantly drives up the cost to build.
Scaffold Law reform is expected to be a major topic in next year’s legislative session as business interests prepare for a concerted lobbying effort to repeal or amend the law. Paul Zuber, vice president of the Business Council of New York State, told City & State earlier this month that groups like his have found common ground with affordable housing advocates who would like to see more construction. “It’s great realizing that there’s a coalition of people that have a broader interest in some of these things,” he said.
Reports suggested the governor was looking into tackling Scaffold Law reform next year as part of an expanded agenda to increase housing production in the state, one of her cornerstone issues. But Hochul had not directly discussed the prospect publicly until Tuesday.
Hochul said the tragedy in Brooklyn does not mean she should “lose sight of the ambition” to take on challenges like reforming the Scaffold Law. “And yes, they'll be real,” she said of those challenges. “We went through this last year when I had to change the insurance liability laws.”
One of the key opponents to Hochul’s successful bid to reform auto insurance laws earlier this year was the influential New York State Trial Lawyers Association. The group may again clash with the governor as it prepares to defend against significant change or repeal of the Scaffold Law. And it set the stage in a statement to City & State in response to the governor’s new comments.
“We must honor those who lost their lives building New York by remaining a national leader in worker protections and safety,” President John Zaremba, president of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association said in a statement. “Every worker deserves to return home safely, especially immigrant workers and workers of color who face disproportionate risks on dangerous job sites. Now is the time to defend and strengthen the Scaffold Safety Law, not weaken it.”
– With reporting by Kate Lisa
NEXT STORY: New York City ‘raided’ MTA funding, per report
