Politics

Criminal justice reformers hope to influence Court of Appeals noms again

The group that killed the governor’s nomination of Hector La Salle as chief judge in 2023 is launching a new campaign to sway a nomination to the state’s top court.

Judge Jenny Rivera, seen here in 2019 at center, has been on the state Court of Appeals since 2013.

Judge Jenny Rivera, seen here in 2019 at center, has been on the state Court of Appeals since 2013. Lori Van Buren/Albany Times Union via Getty Images

It may feel like déjà vu, but Gov. Kathy Hochul is set to kick off her second full term with a decision over a state Court of Appeals appointment – just like in 2023, immediately following her first election. And like then, the Center for Community Alternatives is kicking off a pressure campaign to influence Hochul’s pick. 

Court of Appeals Judge Jenny Rivera’s 14-year term is set to expire in February. Hochul could choose to renominate the jurist then, but at nearly 66 years old, that would mean Rivera would serve less than four years of another term before hitting the mandatory retirement age of 70. So criminal justice advocates at the Center for Community Alternatives are pushing for Hochul to either stick with Rivera for the time being, or nominate someone new who shares her reform-minded, more progressive approach to the bench and who similarly comes from a nonprosecutorial or corporate background. 

“In your time as Governor, you have repeatedly argued that New York must protect its residents when Washington will not,” reads a letter to Hochul signed by over 100 organizations, shared exclusively with City & State. “Many of your legislation and executive actions have done that, but fulfilling that commitment also requires you to use your judicial nomination power to shape the Court of Appeals so that it will give New York’s Constitution and laws their full force, especially in the current moment and the years ahead.”

Signatories include the New York City Democratic Socialists of America, the Working Families Party, 32BJ SEIU, Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, New York Communities for Change, the Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union, VOCAL-NY, New York Lawyers for the Public Interest and United Auto Workers Region 9A.

The Center for Community Alternatives launched a successful campaign four years ago when the chief judge position for the Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court, became open. Hochul initially nominated Justice Hector LaSalle, whom criminal justice activists and labor groups lobbied strongly against. The state Senate ultimately rejected LaSalle after the governor refused to pull the nomination. Hochul tapped one of advocates’ preferred candidates following that, Judge Rowan Wilson, who received swift approval from Democratic legislators. 

“Since your celebrated nomination of Rowan Wilson to be Chief Judge in 2023, the Court of Appeals has increasingly recognized and enforced protections for New Yorkers under our state’s Constitution and laws,” the letter reads. “But sustained movement in this direction is far from guaranteed.”

Specifically, the letter calls for a nominee who will “maintain and expand New York’s tradition of independent state constitutional interpretation,” has  experience “advocating for everyday and marginalized New Yorkers,” and is committed to “making the law’s promise of equal justice real” for historically overpoliced communities. The letter does not suggest any specific names for who that might be if not Rivera.

The Commission on Judicial Nomination is currently accepting applications and recommendations from people interested in filling the upcoming vacancy. The group will release a shortlist of qualified candidates, including potentially Rivera, for the governor to choose a nominee from. It will then be up to the state Senate to provide final approval or rejection.